Navigating the Subscription Economy

Subscriptions can be convenient, but it's important to make sure they provide ongoing value.

A happy woman changes the channels on her television.

In an era where convenience reigns supreme, the subscription model has emerged as the crown jewel of modern commerce. From streaming services and meal kits to software and even car subscriptions, the "subscribe now" button has become ubiquitous in our digital lives. As we increasingly embrace these recurring services, it's crucial to understand both their allure and the hidden costs that come with this new economic paradigm.

While the subscription model isn't new - newspapers and magazines have used it for centuries - the digital revolution has supercharged this business model, allowing it to permeate nearly every aspect of our lives. Someone may wake up to a workout video from a fitness app, brew coffee from a monthly bean subscription, commute while listening to podcasts on a premium audio app, and prepare dinner with ingredients provided by a meal kit service.

A study by Zuora, a subscription marketing firm, found that 74% of adults across 12 countries use subscription services. This proliferation has given rise to what's now known as the "subscription economy" to describe the shift from a product-based economy to one built on recurring services.

The Appeal of Subscriptions

The allure of subscriptions extends beyond mere convenience. These services offer a sense of discovery, introducing consumers to products they might not have chosen themselves. Many subscriptions appear cost-effective compared to one-time purchases, especially for frequently used items or services. Additionally, the exclusive access and members-only perks offered by many subscriptions create a sense of status and belonging.

However, the true genius of the subscription model lies in its psychological underpinnings. Once we have access to a service, we tend to value it more highly - a phenomenon known as the endowment effect. This, combined with our innate loss aversion, makes it challenging to cancel subscriptions, even when they're underutilized. Subscriptions also alleviate the burden of decision-making, appealing to those overwhelmed by choice in our option-saturated world.

The Hidden Costs of Convenience

While subscriptions offer undeniable benefits, they also come with less visible costs. The accumulation of small monthly fees across multiple services can quickly become a significant expense. A study by West Monroe found that the average American spends $237 per month on subscriptions, often underestimating this amount by $133.

Underutilization is another hidden cost. For example, a study revealed that those with gym memberships estimated they would visit 9.5 times per month - but actually averaged only 4.17 visits. This discrepancy between expected and actual use is shared across various subscription types.

In addition, subscription inertia leads many to continue paying for services they no longer use simply because they forget to cancel or find the process cumbersome. Subscription services often capitalize on this by making cancellation difficult or offering tempting discounts to users attempting to unsubscribe.

Price hikes present another challenge. Many services start with low introductory rates that increase over time, counting on customer inertia to maintain subscriptions even at higher prices. Netflix, for instance, has implemented several price increases since its launch, with most subscribers choosing to stay despite the higher costs.

Managing Your Subscriptions

To enjoy the benefits of the subscription economy while avoiding its pitfalls, consider the following strategies:

  • Regularly audit your subscriptions, canceling those that no longer provide sufficient value. For subscriptions with free trials or introductory rates, set reminders to review the service before the full price kicks in.
  • When possible, share subscriptions with family or friends to split costs. Be wary of long-term commitments, favoring monthly subscriptions over annual ones until you're sure of the value provided. Before subscribing, calculate the yearly cost and compare it to buying the product or service outright.
  • Consider rotating subscriptions instead of maintaining multiple similar services simultaneously. For example, you might subscribe to one video streaming service for a few months, then switch to another, allowing you to enjoy various content without ongoing payments to multiple platforms.

The Bottom Line

The subscription economy offers unprecedented convenience and access to a wide range of products and services. But it also presents challenges in managing costs and avoiding subscription creep. By approaching subscriptions mindfully and regularly evaluating their value, we can enjoy the benefits of this model without falling into its potential pitfalls.

The key to mastering the subscription economy is ensuring you get ongoing value from the service. Sometimes, the most powerful move is knowing when to hit "unsubscribe."

About Us

Dort Financial Credit Union is a not-for-profit financial cooperative whose mission is enriching people’s lives… members, employees, community. Unlike other financial institutions, credit union ‘profits’ are returned to the membership in the form of lower loan rates, higher dividend rates, and affordable services.

 Visit Us Online